LOGIN   :::   RECOVER PASS   :::   GET ACCOUNT    
Browse
  • Projects
  • Code (CVS)
  • Forums
  • News
  • Articles
  • Polls
  •  
    OpenCores
  • FAQ
  • CVS HowTo
  • Mission
  • Media
  • Tools
  • Advertise
  • Mirrors
  • Logos
  • Contact us
  • Job Opportunity
  •  
    Tools
  • Search
      
  • Download Cores (CVSGet)
  •  
    More
  • Wishbone
  • Perlilog
  • EDA tools
  • OpenTech CD
  •  
    Navigation: All forums > Cores > Message List > Message Post

    Message

    Reply | Reply all
    Date Prev | Date Next | Thread Prev | Thread Next Date Index | Thread Index

    From: Richard Herveille<richard@h...>
    Date: Thu Aug 2 22:12:14 CEST 2007
    Subject: [oc] GPLv3 usable for open HW
    Top
    [rih] Everybody has their own reasons, and nobody should judge another on
    their motives. It all comes down to what you expect and desire.



    Because i want that if a company uses something i wrote, that
    they give also something back. Yes, GPL might be not the right
    thing (not even for software). But in the current world, where
    it isn't hip for companies to share what they did with open source
    software/hardware with the rest of the world, i'd like to have
    some kind of protection that i might get something back.
    [rih] Personally I get angry when companies borrow code from open source
    designs and then attack the same open source community they so conveniently
    took the original sources from.


    Yes and no. Yes, we are developing hardware, yes, it' costs a
    lot more to produce and distribute it. But i definitly do not
    like to be ripped of by a company if i wrote something non-trivial.
    I don't care if they use it, but i care if they make money with it
    and do not give anything back.
    [rih] What do you mean by 'ripped off'? Do you want a share of the profit?
    Then GPL is definitely not your thing. I (and many others) make money from
    providing design services. Providing cores without restrictions offers a
    stepping stone for companies to use them. I then make money on customer
    specific modifications and additional support.
    I don't see any other way to make a profit out of this.

    Richard



    > Any license that is somewhat vague limits the usability of a core.

    ACK.

    Attila Kinali

    --
    Praised are the Fountains of Shelieth, the silver harp of the waters,
    But blest in my name forever this stream that stanched my thirst!
    -- Deed of Morred
    _______________________________________________
    http://www.opencores.org/mailman/listinfo/cores


    ReferenceAuthor
    [oc] GPLv3 usable for open HWAttila Kinali

     
    Copyright (c) 1999 OPENCORES.ORG. All rights reserved.